i don't subscribe the Hoagland method so admittedly i can not say it is accurate to a fault
therefore it is a very good argument that conservation could still result in a favorable result
i suppose plant size, medium type, environmental differences and so on and on could be factors
either way... we each do what we do
I got 9 plants in a 4x4
4 glns per plant per week in a recirc = 36 glns
so my drain to waste uses 9 more gallons per week thatn what most...
4 gallons of nutrient solution per plant with replacement on a
weekly basis. If any of these parameters is altered, i.e., volume of solution,
number of plants, and frequency of replacement, plant performance can be
significantly affected
347 authored by Hoagland and Arnon (1950). This circular has been the most
widely cited publication in all crop science literature. The scientific literature
is full of hydroponic formulas that are identified as modified Hoagland nutrient
solutions with little given that describes what was...
so I was wondering how much water I actually use
so rather than estimating
I actually collected all my run off for 1 week
the waste was 45 gallons for a 4x4 with 9 plants and 1000 watts
running dtw
that's not really conserving but I bet most use this much for an ebb n flow...
that may be what he meant
I don't know
the lucas formula is a formula where the N and P are equal and the K double the N
referring to the amount of elemental PPM of each individual macro nutrient...
ratio: 1:1:2 NPK
example
60 ppm N
60 ppm P
120 ppm K...
damn... I jst typed a bunch of stuff and poof! lost it
oh hum I will start again but this time shorter lol
I have been running my own nutes for about 5 years.. I made a bunch of mistakes and took many gambles experimenting with all kinds of stuff
ive followed plenty of bad advise from...
I tried googling reverse lucas and got very little
except at rollit up forum had someone talking about it briefly
I think if memory serves
lucas is 1:1:2 npk ratio
so reverse?? 2:1:1 ??
not for me! I wouldn't run that!
that would be something like...
so I run a 4x4 tray =16 sq ft with a 1000 watt light over 9 plants
EC max at 1.1
it has a 100 gln res dtw and it use about 10 glns a day so I get 10 days from 100 gln
my veg tray is a 2x4 =8 sq ft with a 30 gln res and it recirculates
over it I have a 400 watt t5
I...
that sucks.. you sound tired and bummed out
hope youll come back to chat when you get caught up
after all it was you who inspired/requested me to start this thread
then id say you know what your talking about....
i have personally never grown in coco, but i have read that depending on how you mix it you can to some degree control the saturation and how much water it will hold
but since i have no first hand experience i really have no place to...
I mix a 2 part concentrate for my veg res
its not dtw...
since i feed the same ratio in veg from start to finish i mix it to add equal portions of each part until i achieve the desired EC
please don't misunderstand my responses im not looking to argue as I know your not either but I am interested in good conversation and im open
I respect that your environmentally aware and appreciate it
I just want you to consider
the nutes your adding to your med and your body are...
oops I got them crossed....
you are correct dtw might put fractionally more fertilizer waste intot the environment
you are using 1/3 more water but I could likely use less if I was more thoughtful
I could also switch to coco and use considerably less water
but also consider...