It depends... outside of spectrum issues (which is arguable over total impact), the hps will kick out almost a third more lumens initially. This becomes most noticeable over the outside areas & penetration depth... you can go wider & deeper w the hps. Outside of this, both will flower the plant well, though side-by-sides will look/perform differently- nothing to worry on now. With the right hood/set-up, you can cover a 5'x5' with an hps, though outside nugs will be lesser in qual. Best brah.